Charles Arter Cagle

When Charles Arter Cagle was born on February 25, 1844, his father, Henry, was 32 and his mother, Martha, was 29. He married Lydia Margaret Standridge and they had eight children together. He then married Mary Elizabeth Tilley and they had 11 children together. He died on December 20, 1924, at the age of 80, and was buried in Franklin County, Arkansas.

By: Nancy Jane Balmer--Great Great Granddaughter of Lidia Margaret Standridge Cagle

The following is some of the information that we have gathered on the Wagon Train Adventure.

I have 1880 newspapers from Americus, Kansas Notes by Mr. Burow, letters from pension records from family members, who tell of the deaths of the family members who died on the way home from Idaho Territory to Newton County, Arkansas. They were all trying to make it back to Newton County...

In 1879 a group of family members headed their wagons toward Idaho Territory, for the most part, they were all from Newton County, Arkansas and all family members. The names of the families who traveled together were: Cagle, Standridge, Meek/Meeks, Lane, Adams, Nolan, and Rigney. Charles Arter Cagle was a farmer and Baptist Minister who was a driver on the wagon train. Records do not indicate whether he was the head or lead driver of the wagon train. The caravan of families stopped in Wyoming and others in Idaho Territory. Some of the members of the wagon train lived in Albion and some in the 14th District. All were listed in the 1878 and 1880 Idaho Census.

Note by Betty--Lidia Margaret Standridge married Charlie Cagle in 1865. Lidia was a sister to Howard Standridge. Their parents were Lemuel and Margaret Blevins Standridge. Howard Standridge was Granny Renfroe's father and Lidia her aunt.

While there, they worked as farm laborers and cooks, earning and saving what they could so that they might return to Newton County, Arkansas. May 31, 1880, after the census was taken, they lined up their wagons and headed for Newton County. They followed the Oregon Trail, along the Snake River to Idaho and would venture along the same route on their return to Arkansas. It would have taken four to five months to get back to Arkansas. On the way home, some of the family members drank water from a well, river, or other source of contaminated water. They became ill with typhoid fever, resulting in the death of several members of our families who traveled together.

Lydia Margaret "Lidie" Standridge Cagle, became ill and died on September 30,1880 in Ameicus, Lyon County, Kansas, she was the wife of Charles Arter Cagle. Lydia had given birth to her 8th child, Melvira on September 14, 1880, just two weeks prior to her illness and death. Charles loved his wife and wanted to give her a proper burial. He cut off Lydia's long dark hair and sold it to a man who made horse whips out of her hair, in exchange the man provided a proper burial for Lydia. Alexander Standridge died two days before Lydia, Alexander was the son of Jeremiah and Nancy Cagle Standridge and husband of Mary Elizabeth Tilley. Nancy Cagle Standridge, wife of Jeremiah "Jerry" Standridge also died of typhoid fever on October 20, 1880. It is believed that Burton Columbus Cagle about 7 years old, and several other family members also died. Of the eight children born to Charles and Lydia, only five survived. After Lydia's death, Charles hired a wet nurse to feed and take care of his new baby and his small children. The wet nurse hired by Charles, was Mary Elizabeth Tilley Standridge, who would become Charles second wife on March 27, 1881in Newton County, Arkansas, and filed in Pope County, Arkansas. We do believe that our family members are all buried in a cemetery. There was a cemetery called Americus Cemetery in this town in 1880.

We gathered our information from the newspapers-- "Emporia News", under the "Americus Notes"--from September 20 1880 to November 6 1880. These articles (Americus Notes) were written by a man named Burlow, one hundred and twenty two years ago. I do not think that Mr. Burlow would have ever dreamed that his articles would mean so much to our families this many years later.

Notes from Emporia News, Americus, Lyon County, Kansas Americus Notes by Burlow.

Monday September 20, 1880: Two families arrived in Americus, Kansas at the Howard's home on their return trip from Idaho to Arkansas, one man is very sick, this is what caused the delay for the wagon train.

Wednesday September 21 1880 (looks like it should say Tuesday) Five teams of those Arkansas folks arrive at the Howard's home, now there are four sick ones at the Howard's home and you would think it was turned into a hospital.

Wednesday September 22 1880 The sick ones at the hospital are not as well today.

Saturday September 25 1880 The hospital invalids are somewhat better today. The neighbors have resolved themselves into a sanitary committee and many needful things have been brought in to make the sick ones comfortable.

Monday September 27 1880 One of the sick ones at the Howard's house died yesterday and will be buried today. They did not have a name for him. The sick are no better today and the recovery of one or two others is rater improbable. (We believe the man who died to be Alexander Standridge son of Jeremiah and Nancy Cagle Standridge and husband of Mary Elizabeth Tilley Standridge we know from family records that Alexander died two days before or two days after the death of Lydia Margaret Standridge Cagle. This would make his death date September 26, 1880).

Thursday September 30 1880 One family left the hospital and started for "Ar-kan-sas". There are still about 25 left, five of them of whom are down sick at present, with good prospects for more. Typhoid fever seems to be the prevailing disease. One of the women folks (this was Lidia Margaret Standridge Cagle, Nancy Jane Balmer's Great Great Grandmother) were buried to day making the second fatal case from this place. The family that left this morning had three among them that had better have been under the doctor's care.

Saturday October 4, 1880 The sick ones at the hospital are improving since the sanitary committee did such good work for them and a repetition of their losses is not at present expected.

Monday October 6, 1880 Lastest from the hospital, only seven sick, not nine s been reported. Two are dangerously sick, two are improving fast and three without much change for better or worse. Two of the ones that were sick are counted among the well ones now.

Friday October 8 1880 The Americus Hospital is under the charge of Dr. Stover.

Saturday October 9, 1880 All the sick ones are improving.

Thursday October 14, 1880 A child at the hospital by the name of Standridge, died today and was buried after sundown. The latest funeral we ever heard of. Ask Judge Cunningham about the graveyard witness.

Sunday October 17, 1880 The remaining six that are sick at the hospital are on the imporve.

Thursday October 21, 1880 Mrs. Nancy Standridge departed this life at the hospital yesterday morning at 7:30 a.m.. this makes the third one of that family and the fourth one from that place that death has marked as victims.

Thursday October 26, 1880 Hospital sick ones are improving and Standridge proposes to move out next Monday.

Monday November 1, 1880 Charley Cagle (Nancy Jane Balmer's Great Great Grandfather) is quite sick and Dr. Wright has been called to attend him. The rest of the hospital ones are improving fast, but they will not leave for some time yet. The county doctor has not been there since a week ago Saturday.

Saturday Nov 6, 1880 The Americus hospital in en route for Arkansas and ye local reporter "Mourneth for items." By Burlow

(Written just the way it is in the news paper)

Census records of the Families on the Wagon Train:

1880 Census Albion, Cassia County, Idaho (page 161A)

42-42

Cagle, Martha -- H Travling GA GA GA (Martha Isabel Pine Tree)

Margaret 18 D AR GA GA (should be AR TN GA)

Nolan, Charles 21 Boarder CA Ire Ire 

(Martha is the mother of all the Cagle's that went to Idaho Territory

43-43

Cagle, Charles 32 H Farmer TN TN TN 

Lydia 33 W AR TN MO 

Samuel R. 13 S AR TN AR ( Lemuel Riley)

Mary Ann 12 D AR TN AR 

Martha I. 9 D AR TN AR (Martha Isabel)

Burton C. 7 S AR TN AR (Burton Columbus) 

Margaret E. 3 D AR TN AR (Margaret Emeline)

(Margaret Emeline is my gr grandmother)

44-44

Meek, Susan 36 H TN TN TN (Susan Cagle Standridge Meek/Meeks)

Samuel S. 18 S AR TN TN (he was a Standridge)

Jeremiah 13 S AR TN TN

James W. 9 S AR TN TN

Esquire 6 S AR TN TN

45-45 Standridge, Jeremiah 46 H Farmer AR TN TN 

Nancy 43 W TN TN TN (Nancy Cagle)

Isabel 17 D AR AR TN

George W. 12 S AR AR TN (Geroge Washington)

Mary E. 10 D AR AR TN (Mary Elizabeth) 

Grant 6 S AR AR TN (Ulysess S. Grant)

Martha 5 D AR AR TN (Martha Pine Tree)

46-46

Standridge, Richard 36 H Farmer AR TN TN

Nancy J. 39 W KY KY KY (Nancy Jane Felkins)

Samuel W. 15 S AR AR KY

Tennessee 14 D AR AR KY

Louisanna 12 D AR AR KY

Alabama 11 D AR AR KY

George W. 8 S AR AR KY

Arkansas 6 D AR AR KY

Missouri 5 D AR AR KY

James H. 4 S AR AR KY

Virginia 1 S AR AR KY

47-47

Rigney, William 41 Freighter KY TN GA

1880 Census 14th District, Cassia County, Idaho (page 163)

48-48

Standridge, Alexander 40 H Farmer AR AR TN (s/o Jeremiah & Nancy Cagle Standridge)

Mary 20 W AR AR AR (Mary Elizabeth Tilley)

John H. 18 Cousin AR AR TN (s/o John & Susan Cagle Standridge Meek) Laborer

Note: Alexander's age was wrong, he was only 20 yrs old

49-49

Standridge, Alexander 25 H Farmer AR TN TN 

Lucinda 24 W AR AR AR (Lucinda Catherine Ross)

Mary J. 9 D AR AR AR

John W. 6 S AR AR AR

James M. 2 S AR AR AR

50-50

Lane, William J. 24 H Farmer IN IN IN

Mary E. 21 W AR TN TN (Mary E. Cagle)

Notes: married in Ada County, Idaho

51-51

Cagle, James J. 24 H Farmer AR AR AR (should be AR TN GA/TN, s/s Martha Cagle)

Eliza 23 W AR TX TX (Might be AR TN TN) (Eliza Meeks) 

Henry C. 4 S IT AR AR

James L. 2 S AR AR AR

Margaret 9/12 D ID AR AR

52-52

Adams, John 26 Laborer AR MO AR

53-53

Kingsburg, Thomas 48 H Freighter NY NY NY

Daniel 18 S IA NY NY

John 13 S ID NY NY

1880 Sublet Creek, Unita, Wyoming 

June 2, 1880

Household 44 

Meeks, William Head 33 TX

Rebecca Wife 36 TN

Mary Dau 13 AR

Louis Son 10 MO

Margaret Dau 9 AR

Susan Dau 6 AR

Moses Son 10\12 WY

Meek, John brother 15 AR

(We believe that they stopped in Wyoming when Rebecca gave birth to Moses. William and Rebecca and family came back at the same time as the others and they moved to Eufaula, McIntosh County, Oklahoma. William R Meeks was arrested for murder in Eufaula and put into prison, he had family members and friends come and testify that he was in Idaho Territory when the crime was committed and was released. Statements were made that there was 13 wagons on this trip to Idaho Territory.)

Note: Not on the wagon train, but there is a family connection between, William A. Rigney. When the wagon train arrived back home, some of the family stayed in Newton County, Arkansas, other members of the family moved to Eufaula, McIntosh County, Oklahoma. There are probably still more family members we do not know about on this wagon train.

Prepared by : Nancy Jane Mathews Balmer

California

(Geneva Smith, daughter of Sue Cole, lives in Kansas and ordered the reel and copied the information we needed from the Americus Notes. We all thank her. The information was taken from a different newspaper than my information so Mr. Burlow must have put info in different papers. The newspaper that we got our information from had just a few more dates with information in it.) Information shared with Betty Renfroe on April 12, 2003 

Margaret Emeline Cagle Greer Family

William David Cagle, Melvira V.Cagle, John Franklin Cagle, (back row) Nancy Jane, Jesse Morgan Greer, Margaret Emeline Cagle Greer, Sarah Margaret & Charles Arter Cagle w/bible. Charles Cagle married Lydia Margaret Standridge. Picture was taken in Eufaula, McIntosh, Oklahoma.

Charles Cagle was the son of Henry and Martha Cagle. He married Lydia Margaret Standride, daughter of Lemuel and Margaret Blevins Standridge.

Margaret Emeline "Emeline" Cagle was the daughter of Charles Arter Cagle and Lydia Margaret Standridge. She was born October 14, 1875 in Arkansas/Oklahoma, Cherokee Nation. Emeline had Luekemia, she died June 4, 1959 in Lawndale, Los Angeles County, California. Emeline is buried Pacific Crest Cemetery, Redondo Beach, Los Angeles County, California. She first married Jesse Morgan Greer/Grear, February 11, 1894 in Freeman, Pope County, Arkansas, son of Henry Greer and Aramenta Williams. He was born July 13, 1861 in De Soto, Mississippi, died December 7, 1905 in Eufaula, McIntosh County, Oklahoma, Creek Indian Nation. Ememline's second marriage was to Harvey Dustin Phillips, April 1909 in Eufaula, McIntosh County, Oklahoma. He was born March 7, 1849 in Virginia.

Information from Pacific Crest Cemetery
No. 17737 Name Phillips, Margaret Emeline
Grave 6 Lot 200 Sec. 7
Int. Date 6-6-1959 Undertaker McCormick Morturary
Death Date 6-4-1959 Age. 83 Years
Birthplace Oklahoma
Date of Birth 10-14-1876 (It is wrong on the card, 9-14-1876) Margaret Emeline was three years old when her mother died on the way back to Newton County, Arkansas from Idaho on the wagon train. Margaret Emeline was four years old and living in Newton County, Arkansas when she was bitten four times by a rattlesnake before her father could get to her. When Emeline was seven years old she would help her father break wild horses that he had rounded up. After they were broke, Charles would take them to town and sell them.

Jesse Morgan Greer/Grear: Jesse Morgan Greer was born July 13, 1861 in Mississippi, died December 7, 1905, in Oklahoma, Indian Territory. Jesse took a wagon load of blankets to a tribe of indians, who were ill, he became ill with whatever they had and took it home to his family. Jesse, his two small sons, and his mother all died.

Jesse's family
Charlie Huston Greer,(son) B-December 9, 1901 D-October 4, 1905
Aramenta (Williams) Greer (Mother) B-1840 D-December 4, 1905
Jesse Morgan Greer (Cagle's spouse) B-July 13, 1861 D-December 7, 1905
Robert Lee Greer (Son) B-April 8, 1903 D-February 11, 1906

Aramenta Williams Greer was Jesse Morgan's mother. They all died in Creek Indian Territory, Oklahoma. Melvira "Millie" Cagle lived there with them at this time, Margaret Emeline Cagle, had a child who they named Ola Mae Greer, who was born May 21, 1905. Ola never got to know her father. Her sister Nancy Jane Greer was eight years old and Sarah Margaret Greer was only six. We do not know where they are buried, possibly in Greenwood Cemetery because Jesse and Emeline's first child, Martha Jane, is buried there. There is a census of Jesse Morgan Greer and a Melvira Cagle living in the Creek Nation in 1900. The rest of the family is not listed. Melvira is listed as siter instead of sister-in-law.

Harvey Dustin Phillips was the second husband of Marigaret Emeline Cagle, Greer. Lucille Marie Webb, said that Harvey Dustin Phillips was not liked very much buy those who new him, so he didn't have a very nice nick name, "they called him "Missouri Puke". There son Leonard was also a very nice man.

Harvey Phillips had another son, Aunt Ola said his name was Harvey born october 16, ? he died in Colorado. Maybe that is where Harvey died .He used to beat upLil' Gram and one day she ran him off. Harvey was 62 years old and Margaret Emeline Cagle Greer was 33 years old when Leonard Columbus Phillips was born.

Children of Margaret Cagle and Jesse Greer/Grear:
1. Martha Jane Greer, born February 23, 1895 in Eufaula, McIntosh County, Oklahoma; died October 01, 1896 in Eufaula, McIntosh County, Oklahoma.
2. Nancy Jane "Jane" Greer, born February 22, 1897 in Eufaula, McIntosh County, Oklahoma; died October 24, 1972 in Hawthorne, Los Angeles County, California. She married (1) Harvey Dewitt Curts, April 26, 1913 in Eufaula, Mcintosh County, Oklahoma; born 1890. She married (2) Ira Mathews March 27, 1917 in Waurika, Jefferson County, Oklahoma; born October 15, 1877 in Clay Center, Clay County, Kansas; died July 15, 1951 in Torrance, Los Angeles County, California.
Ira and Nancy Jane Mathews came to California in 1922, they resided in Redondo Beach, California in 1922. They resided in Redondo in 1922, their address was 703 Hermosea Ave., Redondo Beach , CA. They then moved to Lawndale.
Before they came to California they lived in Texas. Ira worked for the Boyd Kease Co. Box 1148 was given as Stephen County.
3. Sarah Margaret "Marge" Greer, born November 18, 1899 in Eufaula, Mcintosh County, Oklahoma (Indian Territory); died September 13, 1982 in Ada, Pontotoc County, Oklahoma. She married (1) Walter August Rottman; born August 28, 1897 in Nebraska; died August 31, 1970 in Long Beach, Los Angeles County, California. She married (2) Jesse Dot Smith March 3, 1917 in Healdton, Carter County, Oklahoma; born November 17, 1897 in Blanco County, Texas; died April 4, 1937 in Ada, Pontotoc County, Oklahoma.
While working on an Oil Derick in Harden City, Sunday, Jesse Smith was killed when the scaffold he was walking across broke and he fell 28 feet to the floor of the Oil Rig. He lived about 15 minutes but died before the ambulance could get to the hospital. Workers said that upon arriving for work they found they did not have enough scaffolding and some workers were sent to Ardmore, Ok. to get some more. When the scaffolling was put in place and Smith walked across it it broke where there was a knot in the board. Mr. Smith had worked for Oklahoma Rig Company for about 3 years and was survived by a wife and five children in Ada, Okla. Jesse Dot Smith was known for his fiddle playing from Oklahoma to California. My father, Robert Mathews, said he can remember Uncle Jesse's fiddle playing and said he was the best fiddle player he had ever heard.
4. Charles Huston Greer, born December 9, 1901 in Eufaula, McIntosh County, Oklahoma Indian Territory; died October 4, 1905 in Eufaula, McIntosh County, Oklahoma Indian Territory. He is buried Greenwood Cemetey, Eufaula, McIntosh County, Oklahoma.
5. Robert Lee Greer, born April 8, 1903 in Eufaula, McIntosh County Oklahoma Indian Territory; died February 11, 1906 in Eufaula. He is buried Greenwood Cemetey, Eufaula, McIntosh County, Oklahoma
6. Ola Mae "Olie" Greer, born May 21, 1905 in Duston, Hughes County, Oklahoma Creek Indian Territory; died October 1, 1994 in Torrance, Los Angeles County, California. She married (1) William Roy Frye in Oklahoma. She married (2) Carlos Brody Proctor; born 1902 in New Mexico. Notes for Ola Mae "Olie" Greer:


Child of Margaret Cagle and Harvey Phillips is:
1. Leonard Cloumbus Phillips, born September 24, 1911 in Fitzhugh, Pototoc County, Oklahoma; died July 08, 1980 in Perris, California. He married Mary Mudge September 22, 1961 in Las Vegas, Clark County, Neveda; born 1916. Notes for Leonard Columbus Phillips: Leonard Phillips father was 62 years old when he was born, Margaret Emeline Cagle Greer Phillips was 33 years old. Leonard is buried Riverside National Cemetery Riverside, California